Username:
Comment:

Check here

Greebo

WTF?

Crew

Heads I win, tails you lose?

CT

If no evolutionary pathway can be envisioned this should be a point for creationism.

Hmmm... so, if they can't envision an evolutionary pathway... in other words, come up with a plausible scenario of how the evolution of something happened... then it should be a point for Creationism?

Sure, evolutionists may come up with a plausible scenario -- they're good at that -- but as it stands this is a decent argument against and should be tallied for the creationists.

Err... you admit that they CAN come up with a plausible scenario... in other words, they CAN envision an evolutionary pathway.


That is your idea of a decent argument?? You shot the damned thing down yourself!

David D.G.

Not only does science not work that way, but you are advocating a false dichotomy. If evolutionary theory gets shot down, it gets shot down -- but that in itself doesn't put one iota of evidence forward to support either ID or creationism. There may be some other explanation entirely.

You need to come up with positive evidence for creationism to have ANY support for it, no matter what happens regarding evolutionary theory or ID; and since evolution has all the evidence in favor of it so far, and you have none at all in favor of creationism so far, I would say that evolution is pretty darned far out in front.


~David D.G.

"I dunno goddidit" counts as a point for creationists?

"What's the capital of Zaire?"
"I dunno goddidit."


Another point for creationists I guess.